live

Replay codeguardian-run-003

Audit async side effects for unchecked failures.

#1 · 2026-04-26T00:20:00.000Z

Task received

task_receivedhybrid

CodeGuardian accepted the allowlisted audit task: Audit async side effects for unchecked failures.

goal

Audit async side effects for unchecked failures.

target

examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "target": "examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts",
  "goal": "Audit async side effects for unchecked failures.",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#2 · 2026-04-26T00:20:01.000Z

Context loaded

context_loadedhybrid

Loaded the demo source fixture and hashed the context for examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts.

sourceHash

sha256:79fabb8f811fd1fb260468b81663b19269a16979aca4f3c2908c28b968e9cfa3

byteLength

259

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "target": "examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts",
  "sourceHash": "sha256:79fabb8f811fd1fb260468b81663b19269a16979aca4f3c2908c28b968e9cfa3",
  "byteLength": 259,
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#3 · 2026-04-26T00:20:02.000Z

Analysis started

compute_startedlive

Started the compute-backed analysis run zg-live-analysis-95bb0f30184d through 0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836.

runId

zg-live-analysis-95bb0f30184d

provider

0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836

model

qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "runId": "zg-live-analysis-95bb0f30184d",
  "model": "qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct",
  "provider": "0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836",
  "source": "live"
}

#4 · 2026-04-26T00:20:04.000Z

Analysis completed

compute_completedlive

Completed analysis run zg-live-analysis-95bb0f30184d and recorded its output hash.

runId

zg-live-analysis-95bb0f30184d

outputHash

sha256:3bd121aaf0db03f3c838b67f3aac34d0bde2cde27ef85eaecd4bbd762265e3a3

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "runId": "zg-live-analysis-95bb0f30184d",
  "outputHash": "sha256:3bd121aaf0db03f3c838b67f3aac34d0bde2cde27ef85eaecd4bbd762265e3a3",
  "source": "live"
}

#5 · 2026-04-26T00:20:05.000Z

Issue found

issue_foundlive

A failed awaited side effect can escape without explicit classification or recovery.

issue

A failed awaited side effect can escape without explicit classification or recovery.

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "issue": "A failed awaited side effect can escape without explicit classification or recovery.",
  "source": "live"
}

#6 · 2026-04-26T00:20:07.000Z

Patch proposed

patch_proposedlive

Wrap the awaited side effect in explicit error handling and return a typed failure result.

patch

Wrap the awaited side effect in explicit error handling and return a typed failure result.

Patch diff

diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts
@@
 export async function saveAuditResult(
   id: string,
   writeAudit: (id: string) => Promise<void>,
 ): Promise<SaveResult> {
-  await writeAudit(id);
+  try {
+    await writeAudit(id);
+  } catch (error) {
+    return {
+      ok: false,
+      reason: error instanceof Error ? error.message : "audit write failed",
+    };
+  }
   return { ok: true, id };
 }

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "patch": "Wrap the awaited side effect in explicit error handling and return a typed failure result.",
  "patchDiff": "diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts\n@@\n export async function saveAuditResult(\n   id: string,\n   writeAudit: (id: string) => Promise<void>,\n ): Promise<SaveResult> {\n-  await writeAudit(id);\n+  try {\n+    await writeAudit(id);\n+  } catch (error) {\n+    return {\n+      ok: false,\n+      reason: error instanceof Error ? error.message : \"audit write failed\",\n+    };\n+  }\n   return { ok: true, id };\n }\n",
  "source": "live"
}

#7 · 2026-04-26T00:20:08.000Z

Critic loop started

critic_startedlive

Started the self-review critic loop run zg-live-critic-a83aa740043a.

runId

zg-live-critic-a83aa740043a

provider

0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836

model

qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "runId": "zg-live-critic-a83aa740043a",
  "model": "qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct",
  "provider": "0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836",
  "source": "live"
}

#8 · 2026-04-26T00:20:10.000Z

Critic completed

critic_completedlive

Accepted the patch after critique: The patch addresses the issue by ensuring that any errors from awaited side effects are handled explicitly. However, it is important to provide more context on...

accepted

true

critique

The patch addresses the issue by ensuring that any errors from awaited side effects are handled explicitly. However, it is important to provide more context on how the failure res...

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "critique": "The patch addresses the issue by ensuring that any errors from awaited side effects are handled explicitly. However, it is important to provide more context on how the failure result will be used and ensure that the error handling is robust and clear. Consider adding detailed error messages and specifying the type of failure for better debugging and maintenance.",
  "accepted": true,
  "source": "live"
}

#9 · 2026-04-26T00:20:11.000Z

Memory delta created

memory_delta_createdhybrid

Wrap awaited side effects in explicit error handling.

learnedPattern

Wrap awaited side effects in explicit error handling.

memoryDelta

Added an async side-effect handling pattern to persistent review memory.

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "learnedPattern": "Wrap awaited side effects in explicit error handling.",
  "memoryDelta": "Added an async side-effect handling pattern to persistent review memory.",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#10 · 2026-04-26T00:20:12.000Z

Memory written

memory_writtenlive

Advanced persistent memory to version 3.

version

3

memoryRoot

sha256:a2398bbb0b7b561c7fa891cf7a808f81991996cc1bce29b01dc0d6010ac11c72

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "memoryRoot": "sha256:a2398bbb0b7b561c7fa891cf7a808f81991996cc1bce29b01dc0d6010ac11c72",
  "version": 3,
  "source": "live"
}

#11 · 2026-04-26T00:20:13.000Z

Policy upgrade checked

skill_upgrade_checkedhybrid

Checked dynamic upgrade rules; no policy upgrade was needed.

upgraded

false

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "upgraded": false,
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#12 · 2026-04-26T00:20:14.000Z

Trace committed

trace_committedlive

Committed the replay trace root for verification.

traceRoot

sha256:655cb96747a2141f62ddc78a16e4b2c39fd5a80e413358bc40ba7bdc125f3c7c

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "traceRoot": "sha256:655cb96747a2141f62ddc78a16e4b2c39fd5a80e413358bc40ba7bdc125f3c7c",
  "source": "live"
}

#13 · 2026-04-26T00:20:15.000Z

Certificate issued

certificate_issuedlive

Issued Proof-of-Intelligence certificate poi-cert-codeguardian-001.

certificateId

poi-cert-codeguardian-001

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "certificateId": "poi-cert-codeguardian-001",
  "source": "live"
}

Result

A failed awaited side effect can escape without explicit classification or recovery.

Wrap the awaited side effect in explicit error handling and return a typed failure result.

Patch diff

diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts
@@
 export async function saveAuditResult(
   id: string,
   writeAudit: (id: string) => Promise<void>,
 ): Promise<SaveResult> {
-  await writeAudit(id);
+  try {
+    await writeAudit(id);
+  } catch (error) {
+    return {
+      ok: false,
+      reason: error instanceof Error ? error.message : "audit write failed",
+    };
+  }
   return { ok: true, id };
 }

Raw result JSONPatch, critique, and roots

{
  "issue": "A failed awaited side effect can escape without explicit classification or recovery.",
  "patch": "Wrap the awaited side effect in explicit error handling and return a typed failure result.",
  "patchDiff": "diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/unchecked-async-side-effect.ts\n@@\n export async function saveAuditResult(\n   id: string,\n   writeAudit: (id: string) => Promise<void>,\n ): Promise<SaveResult> {\n-  await writeAudit(id);\n+  try {\n+    await writeAudit(id);\n+  } catch (error) {\n+    return {\n+      ok: false,\n+      reason: error instanceof Error ? error.message : \"audit write failed\",\n+    };\n+  }\n   return { ok: true, id };\n }\n",
  "critique": "The patch addresses the issue by ensuring that any errors from awaited side effects are handled explicitly. However, it is important to provide more context on how the failure result will be used and ensure that the error handling is robust and clear. Consider adding detailed error messages and specifying the type of failure for better debugging and maintenance.",
  "accepted": true,
  "memoryRoot": "sha256:a2398bbb0b7b561c7fa891cf7a808f81991996cc1bce29b01dc0d6010ac11c72"
}