hybrid

Replay codeguardian-run-002

Audit access control before returning private records.

#1 · 2026-04-26T00:10:00.000Z

Task received

task_receivedhybrid

CodeGuardian accepted the allowlisted audit task: Audit access control before returning private records.

goal

Audit access control before returning private records.

target

examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "target": "examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts",
  "goal": "Audit access control before returning private records.",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#2 · 2026-04-26T00:10:01.000Z

Context loaded

context_loadedhybrid

Loaded the demo source fixture and hashed the context for examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts.

sourceHash

sha256:5679a44382c8be899652ee71b64f2b1adcecb28a4db86e089f7c3677c1cd64a9

byteLength

455

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "target": "examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts",
  "sourceHash": "sha256:5679a44382c8be899652ee71b64f2b1adcecb28a4db86e089f7c3677c1cd64a9",
  "byteLength": 455,
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#3 · 2026-04-26T00:10:02.000Z

Analysis started

compute_startedhybrid

Started the compute-backed analysis run zg-hybrid-analysis-002 through 0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836.

runId

zg-hybrid-analysis-002

provider

0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836

model

qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "runId": "zg-hybrid-analysis-002",
  "model": "qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct",
  "provider": "0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#4 · 2026-04-26T00:10:04.000Z

Analysis completed

compute_completedhybrid

Completed analysis run zg-hybrid-analysis-002 and recorded its output hash.

runId

zg-hybrid-analysis-002

outputHash

sha256:52a61a030d9a99fd63a37ec5ae502438733a389b90c583f28606f3d17eef2e4d

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "runId": "zg-hybrid-analysis-002",
  "outputHash": "sha256:52a61a030d9a99fd63a37ec5ae502438733a389b90c583f28606f3d17eef2e4d",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#5 · 2026-04-26T00:10:05.000Z

Issue found

issue_foundhybrid

Private records can be returned before verifying the caller owns the account.

issue

Private records can be returned before verifying the caller owns the account.

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "issue": "Private records can be returned before verifying the caller owns the account.",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#6 · 2026-04-26T00:10:07.000Z

Patch proposed

patch_proposedhybrid

Check authorization before reading or returning private records, and fail closed when ownership cannot be proven.

patch

Check authorization before reading or returning private records, and fail closed when ownership cannot be proven.

Patch diff

diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts
@@
 export async function loadPrivateRecord(
   callerAccountId: string,
   requestedAccountId: string,
   readRecord: (accountId: string) => Promise<PrivateRecord>,
   canRead: (caller: string, requested: string) => Promise<boolean>,
 ) {
+  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {
+    return null;
+  }
  const record = await readRecord(requestedAccountId);
-  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {
-    return null;
-  }
   return record;
 }

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "patch": "Check authorization before reading or returning private records, and fail closed when ownership cannot be proven.",
  "patchDiff": "diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts\n@@\n export async function loadPrivateRecord(\n   callerAccountId: string,\n   requestedAccountId: string,\n   readRecord: (accountId: string) => Promise<PrivateRecord>,\n   canRead: (caller: string, requested: string) => Promise<boolean>,\n ) {\n+  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {\n+    return null;\n+  }\n  const record = await readRecord(requestedAccountId);\n-  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {\n-    return null;\n-  }\n   return record;\n }\n",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#7 · 2026-04-26T00:10:08.000Z

Critic loop started

critic_startedhybrid

Started the self-review critic loop run zg-hybrid-critic-002.

runId

zg-hybrid-critic-002

provider

0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836

model

qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "runId": "zg-hybrid-critic-002",
  "model": "qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-instruct",
  "provider": "0xa48f01287233509FD694a22Bf840225062E67836",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#8 · 2026-04-26T00:10:10.000Z

Critic completed

critic_completedhybrid

Accepted the patch after critique: The fix moves authorization ahead of disclosure and preserves the function's narrow data access boundary.

accepted

true

critique

The fix moves authorization ahead of disclosure and preserves the function's narrow data access boundary.

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "critique": "The fix moves authorization ahead of disclosure and preserves the function's narrow data access boundary.",
  "accepted": true,
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#9 · 2026-04-26T00:10:11.000Z

Memory delta created

memory_delta_createdhybrid

Verify authorization before returning private records.

learnedPattern

Verify authorization before returning private records.

memoryDelta

Added an authorization-check heuristic to critic reviews.

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "learnedPattern": "Verify authorization before returning private records.",
  "memoryDelta": "Added an authorization-check heuristic to critic reviews.",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#10 · 2026-04-26T00:10:12.000Z

Memory written

memory_writtenhybrid

Advanced persistent memory to version 2.

version

2

memoryRoot

sha256:568cb2b7f31804eef4dbe0231c5bb82ffb3e669a4a726943bc7e6d8c4f835ba2

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "memoryRoot": "sha256:568cb2b7f31804eef4dbe0231c5bb82ffb3e669a4a726943bc7e6d8c4f835ba2",
  "version": 2,
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#11 · 2026-04-26T00:10:13.000Z

Policy upgrade checked

skill_upgrade_checkedhybrid

Recorded a dynamic policy upgrade for future reviews.

upgraded

true

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "upgraded": true,
  "upgrade": {
    "skill": "critic-loop",
    "oldVersion": "0.1.0",
    "newVersion": "0.1.1",
    "oldHash": "sha256:c88eb62cb4deeaa9dce46fa512f30276a4d6c93620e51da886f87d0474f9e4a9",
    "newHash": "sha256:105b17eb2621b0c6591e097f1fc0ebd81b8c6596b46efe2b7404e420173de20c",
    "reason": "After detecting a missing authorization guard, CodeGuardian added an authorization-check heuristic to future critic reviews.",
    "runId": "codeguardian-run-002"
  },
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#12 · 2026-04-26T00:10:14.000Z

Trace committed

trace_committedhybrid

Committed the replay trace root for verification.

traceRoot

sha256:0b1397e29e41dd2e2738c8ffdbb2ac027f8bae46173a763c79cee8a769418ad4

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "traceRoot": "sha256:0b1397e29e41dd2e2738c8ffdbb2ac027f8bae46173a763c79cee8a769418ad4",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

#13 · 2026-04-26T00:10:15.000Z

Certificate issued

certificate_issuedhybrid

Issued Proof-of-Intelligence certificate poi-cert-codeguardian-001.

certificateId

poi-cert-codeguardian-001

Raw event JSONFull canonical event detail

{
  "certificateId": "poi-cert-codeguardian-001",
  "source": "hybrid"
}

Result

Private records can be returned before verifying the caller owns the account.

Check authorization before reading or returning private records, and fail closed when ownership cannot be proven.

Patch diff

diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts
@@
 export async function loadPrivateRecord(
   callerAccountId: string,
   requestedAccountId: string,
   readRecord: (accountId: string) => Promise<PrivateRecord>,
   canRead: (caller: string, requested: string) => Promise<boolean>,
 ) {
+  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {
+    return null;
+  }
  const record = await readRecord(requestedAccountId);
-  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {
-    return null;
-  }
   return record;
 }

Raw result JSONPatch, critique, and roots

{
  "issue": "Private records can be returned before verifying the caller owns the account.",
  "patch": "Check authorization before reading or returning private records, and fail closed when ownership cannot be proven.",
  "patchDiff": "diff --git a/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts b/examples/codeguardian/fixtures/missing-auth-guard.ts\n@@\n export async function loadPrivateRecord(\n   callerAccountId: string,\n   requestedAccountId: string,\n   readRecord: (accountId: string) => Promise<PrivateRecord>,\n   canRead: (caller: string, requested: string) => Promise<boolean>,\n ) {\n+  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {\n+    return null;\n+  }\n  const record = await readRecord(requestedAccountId);\n-  if (!(await canRead(callerAccountId, requestedAccountId))) {\n-    return null;\n-  }\n   return record;\n }\n",
  "critique": "The fix moves authorization ahead of disclosure and preserves the function's narrow data access boundary.",
  "accepted": true,
  "memoryRoot": "sha256:568cb2b7f31804eef4dbe0231c5bb82ffb3e669a4a726943bc7e6d8c4f835ba2",
  "policyUpgrade": {
    "skill": "critic-loop",
    "oldVersion": "0.1.0",
    "newVersion": "0.1.1",
    "oldHash": "sha256:c88eb62cb4deeaa9dce46fa512f30276a4d6c93620e51da886f87d0474f9e4a9",
    "newHash": "sha256:105b17eb2621b0c6591e097f1fc0ebd81b8c6596b46efe2b7404e420173de20c",
    "reason": "After detecting a missing authorization guard, CodeGuardian added an authorization-check heuristic to future critic reviews.",
    "runId": "codeguardian-run-002"
  }
}